Showing posts with label Demons. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Demons. Show all posts

June 18, 2007

Book Group Woes

OK, I made a mistake. Make that two mistakes. I picked a difficult first book and a terrible, filthy second book.

To those that have been reading Demons, I'm sorry. This book is too long. I'm mired on page 600-something, and I'm still not sure what, if anything, is going on. Demons is no Crime and Punishment, which remains a personal favorite.

To those that have purchased Absurdistan, I'm double sorry. If you started reading it, I'm even more sorry. It should be renamed "Obscene"istan. Don't get me wrong, this was a clever book, but I couldn't tolerate the unnecessary sexual remarks and bathroom humor. After 30 pages, I filed it where it belongs--directly in the trash. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I never would have selected this book had I known how crass it would be.

So, after two resounding failures, let me invite you to join me over the next few months as we read several great books. Here's the list:

July: Brigham Young: American Moses by Leonard Arrington
August: Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows by J.K. Rowling
September: The Year of Magical Thinking by Joan Didion and A Grief Observed by C.S. Lewis
October: Alexander Hamilton by Ron Chernow
November: The Omnivore's Dilemma: A Natural History of Four Meals by Michael Pollan

May 05, 2007

Book Group: Demons Part One

I would like to apologize for missing my first deadline of April 20. I will try to be better in the future. Without further ado, here is the first of what I hope will be many great discussions about books.

We are reading Demons in three parts according to the following schedule:

Part I - April 20
Part II - May 11
Part III - June 1

In this post I will discuss Part I, pages 1-206 in the Vintage Classics paperback edition, through a series of passages and questions.

Similar to Brothers Karamazov, Dostoevsky starts this novel with a verse from the Bible. In Demons it is Luke 8:32-36, which reads as follows:

Now a large herd of swine was feeding there on the hillside; and they
begged him to let them enter these. So he gave them leave. Then
the demons came out of the man and entered the swine, and the herd rushed down
the steep bank into the lake and were drowned.

When the herdsman saw what had happened, they fled, and told it in the city
and in the country. Then people went out to see what had happened, and they
came to Jesus, and found the man from whom the demons had gone, sitting at
the feet of Jesus, clothed and in his right mind; and they were afraid. And
those who had seen it told them how he who had been possessed with demons was
healed.

Why do you think Dostoevsky chose this verse? Did you notice anything in Part I that added meaning to the verse?

I found some clues in this passage on pages 25-26:

you cannot imagine what sorrow and anger seize one's whole soul when a
great idea, which one has long and piously revered, is picked up by some
bunglers and dragged into the street, to more fools like themselves, and one
suddenly meets it in the flea market unrecognizable, dirty, askew, absurdly
presented, without proportion, without harmony, a toy for stupid
children!
I believe the above passage describes the course this novel will take--certain great ideas, "long and piously revered" will be "picked up by some bunglers and dragged into the street," only to be disclosed as "unrecognizable, dirty, askew, absurdly presented, without proportion, without harmony, a toy for stupid children."

As I mentioned in my original post, Demons is about ideas run amok. Part I is essentially an extended introduction to the main characters and their Demons. As I read Part I, I had a hard time "rooting" for one character as a protagonist. They all appear quite devious.

Did you identify with any one character? If so, why?

On a "day of surprisingly converging accidents," Part I culminates on page 203 with Shatov striking Nikolai Vsevolodovich:

Shatov, who had been completely forgotten by all in his corner(not far from
Lizaveta Nikolaevna), and who apparently did not know himself why he was sitting
there and would not go away, suddenly rose from his chair and walked across the
entire room, with unhurried but firm steps, towards Nikolai Vsevolodovich,
looking him straight in the face. The latter noticed him approaching from
afar and grinned slightly: but when Shatov came up close to him, he ceased
grinning.

When Shatov stopped silently in front of him, without taking his eyes off
him, everyone suddenly noticed it and became hushed, Pyotr Stepanovich last of
all; Liza and her maman stopped in the middle of the room. Thus about five
seconds went by; the expression of bold perplexity on Nikolai Vsevolodovich's
face turned to wrath, he frowned, and suddenly . . .

And suddenly Shatov swung his long, heavy arm and hit him in the face with
all his might. Nikolai Vsevolodovich swayed badly on his feet.

Shatov hit him even somehow peculiarly, not at all as people ordinarily slap
someone in the face (if it is possible to put it so), not with his palm, but
with his whole fist, and his was a big, heavy, bony fist, covered with red hair
and freckles. if he had hit the nose, he would have broken it. But the blow
landed on the cheek, touching the left corner of the lip and the upper teeth,
which immediately started to bleed.

Then the narrator proceeds to describe Nicolai Vsevolodovich's character and his response as follows:

Nicolai Vsevolodovich was one of those natures that knows no fear. In a duel
he would stand cold-bloodedly before his adversary's fir, take aim himself, and
kill with brutal calm. If anyone had slapped him in the face then, I think he
would not even have challenged the offender to a duel, but would have killed him
at once, on the spot; he was precisely that sort, and would kill with full
awareness and not at all in rage. I even think that he never knew those blinding
fits of wrath that make one unable to reason. For all the boundless anger that
would occasionally take possession of him, he was always able to preserve
complete self-control, and therefore to realize that for killing someone
otherwise than in a duel he would certainly be sent to hard labor; nevertheless,
he would still have killed the offender, and that without the slightest
hesitation.

. . .

And yet, in the present case, something different and wondrous occurred.

As soon as he straightened up, after having swayed so disgracefully to one
side, almost as much as half his height, from the slap he had received, and
before the mean, somehow as if wet, sound of a fist hitting a face seemed to
have faded away in the room, he immediately seized Shatov by the shoulders with
both hands; but immediately, at almost the same moment, he jerked both hands
back and clasped them behind him. He said nothing, looked at Shatov, and turned
pale as a shirt. But strangely, his eyes seemed to be dying out. Ten seconds
later his look was cold and--I'm convinced I'm not lying--calm. Only he
was terribly pale. Of course, I do not know what was inside the man, I
only saw the outside. It seems to me that if there were such a man, for
example, as would seize a red-hot bar of iron and clutch it in his hand, with
the purpose of measuring his strength of mind, and in the course of ten seconds
would be overcoming the intolerable pain and would finally overcome it, this
man, it seems to me, would endure something like what was experienced now, in
these ten seconds, by Nikolai Vsevolodovich.

Shatov leaves the room "softly, his shoulders hunched up somehow especially awkwardly, his head bowed, and as if he were reasoning something out with himself."

Why do you think Shatov challenged Nikolai Vsevolodovich? Why do you think Nikolai Vsevolodovich resisted his natural response to kill Shatov "at once, on the spot"? What do you think Shatov was thinking as he exited the room?

I'm anxious to hear your thoughts generally and your response to the above questions. I will initiate another post on May 11, when we will discuss Part II.

April 17, 2007

Book Group: Helps for Understanding Demons

For those of you working to complete the first part of Demons before Friday, here are a few helps sent by Chantalle:

http://community.middlebury.edu/~beyer/courses/previous/ru351/novels/devils/devil.shtml

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Possessed_(novel)

http://ourworld.compuserve.com/homepages/jim_forest/pevear.htm

Please be warned that the above links contain information that may spoil the plot.

Dostoevsky isn't easy to understand, partly because of the number and complexity of his characters. I have posted a list of characters below. I suggest printing it and using it as a bookmark.

I look forward to discussing Part 1 Friday.

A List of Characters from "Demons" by Fyodor Dostoevsky

Russian names are composed of first name, patronymic (from the father’s first name), and family name. Formal address requires the use of first name and patronymic; diminutives are commonly used among family and intimate friends; a shortened form of the patronymic (e.g. Yegorych instead of Yegorovich), used only in speech, also suggests a certain familiarity. Among the aristocracy, who spoke French at least as readily as Russian, the French forms of names were frequently used, such as Julie in place of Yulia.


  • Alexei Yegorovich, or Yegorych (no family name)
  • Drozdov, Mavriky Nikolaevich (Maurice) – a visiting gentleman and guest of Varvara Petrovna Stavrogin.
  • Drozdov, Praskovya Ivanovna (Drozdikha)
  • Erkel (no first name or patronymic)
  • Fyodor Fyodorovich, called “Fedka the Convict” (no family name) – a roaming criminal suspected of several thefts and murders in the novel.
  • Gaganov, Artemy Pavlovich
  • Gaganov, Pavel Pavlovich
  • G_____v, Anton Lavrentievich
  • Karmazinov, Semyon Yegorovich
  • Kirillov, Alexei Nilych – a Russian engineer who has been driven insane by the thoughts of God and life after death.
  • Lebyadkin, Ignat, called “Captain Lebyadkin” (patronymic “Timofeevich never used) – the drunken former officer whose sister is secretly married to Nicolas.
  • Lebyadkin, Marya Timofeevna, or Timofevna – Captain Lebyadkin's sister, rumored to have some connection to Nikolai Stavrogin's past.
  • Liputin, Sergei Yegorovich (or Vasilyich)
  • Lyamshin (no patronymic or family name)
  • Semyon Yakovlevich (no family name)
  • Shatov, Darya Pavlovna (Dasha)
  • Shatov, Ivan Pavlovich (Shatushka) – a son of former serf to the Stavrogin, former university student and another intellectual who has turned his back on his leftist ideas. This change of heart is what attractes Pyotr Stepanovich Verkhovensky to plot Shatov's murder.
  • Verkhovensky, Marya Ignatievna (Marie)
  • Shigalyov (no first name or patronymic)
  • Stavrogin, Nikolai Vsevolodovich (Nicolas) – the main character of the novel, and a complex figure, he has several inhuman traits about him that resemble a vampire in literature.
  • Stavrogin, Varvara Petrovna – Nicolas’s mother, a rich lady who plays at being leftist.
  • Tikhon – a bishop who, in Dostoevsky's original drafts, Stavrogin visited for guidance, and revealed some of the disturbing events of his past. Their interview has little effect on Stavrogin, but provides the reader a better understanding of his background. This chapter was not accepted by the censors and Dostoevsky excised it from the original version, in which Bishop Tikhon is not mentioned. The Pevear and Volokhonsky translation includes this chapter, called "At Tikhon's" in an appendix.
  • Tolkachenko (no first name or patronymic)
  • Tushin, Lizaveta Nikolaevna (Liza, Lise)
  • Ulitin, Sofya Marveevna
  • Verkhovensky, Pyotor Stepanovich (Petrusha, Pierre) – the son of Stepan and the cause of much of the destruction. He plays at being a true believer revolutionary though his only goal is to have power.
  • Verkhovensky, Stepan Trofimovich – the philosopher and intellectual that is partly to blame for the revolutionary ideas that fuel the destruction that occurs in the book. He served as a father figure to Nicolas when Stavrogin was a child.
  • Virginsky (no first name or patronymic)
  • Virginsky, Arina Prokhorovna
  • von Blum, Andrei Antonovich
  • von Lembke, Andrei Antonovich (also called “Lembka”)
  • von Lembke, Yulia Mikhailovna (Julie)

March 27, 2007

Book Group: Demons by Fyodor Dostoevsky

With all my talk about books, I thought it would be nice if we all read the same book at the same time, followed by an online discussion. With that in mind, I invite you to join me as I read the following books over the next several months, at the rate of one book every one to two months (depending on the size of the book), and according to the loose schedule indicated below:

1. Demons by Fyodor Dostoevsky (April-May)
2. Absurdistan: A Novel by Gary Shteyngart (June)
3. Brigham Young: American Moses by Leonard Arrington (July)
4. Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows by J.K. Rowling (August)
5. The Year of Magical Thinking by Joan Didion; and A Grief Observed by C.S. Lewis (September)
6. Alexander Hamilton by Ron Chernow (October)
6. The Omnivore's Dilemma: A Natural History of Four Meals by Michael Pollan (November)
7. READER'S CHOICE (December)

For those that decide to join me in reading the above-listed books, please recommend a favorite book, or something on your reading list, for the month of December. It would be fun to read something that I didn't pick.

Now, rather than burden you with administrative details or with a pathetic plea to read along and participate in what is sure to be a delightful discussion of each book, let me introduce our first book--Demons by Fyodor Dostoevsky.

Demons by Fyodor Dostoevsky
Inspired by the true story of a political murder that horrified Russians in 1869, Fyodor Dostoevsky conceived of Demons as a "novel-pamphlet" in which he would say everything about the plague of materialist ideology that he saw infecting his native land. What emerged was a prophetic and ferociously funny masterpiece of ideology and murder in pre-revolutionary Russia.

From the forward
Demons is a novel of ideas run amok.

"Here, in what many consider the darkest of his novels, Dostoevsky inscribes the fundamental freedom of Judeo-Christian revelation--the freedom to turn from evil, the freedom to repent."

"The demons, then, are ideas, that legion of isms that came to Russia from the West; idealism, rationalism, empiricism, materialism, utilitarianism, positivism, socialism, anarchism, nihilism, and, underlying them all, atheism."

"The world reflected in the novel is already in a state of parody. . . . The issues, the passions, the oppositions, the polemics, the conspiracies are serious, all too serious. It may be said that this world is in a very serious state of parody (demons always want to be taken seriously)."

Translation
Several individuals have translated this book into English. Some call it "The Possessed"; others call it "Devils"; and still others call it "Demons." After reading various translations of Dostoevsky's other novels, I recommend reading the new translation by Richard Pevear and larissa Volokhonsky. Here are links to buy a copy from Amazon.com: paperback / hardcover.

Reading schedule
Demons is a large book, consisting of three parts. I will be reading each part according to the following schedule:

Part I - April 20
Part II - May 11
Part III - June 1

I will initiate discussion for each part on or after the date listed above.

Dostoevsky
Here are two links with more information on Dostoevsky, the man and his writing:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fyodor_Dostoevsky

http://www.eckerd.edu/academics/qfm/qfm%20files/Foltz%20-%20Dostoevsky%20Study%20Guide.pdf

Happy reading!!