Showing posts with label Book Review. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Book Review. Show all posts

April 14, 2007

Book Review: By the Hand of Mormon: The American Scripture that Launched a New World Religion by Terryl L. Givens

Grade: A

"Though argument does not create conviction, lack of it destroys belief. What seems to be proved may not be embraced; but what no one shows the ability to defend is quickly abandoned. Rational argument does not create belief, but it maintains a climate in which belief may flourish." -Austin Ferrer

In By the Hand of Mormon, Terryl Givens examines why the Book of Mormon "has been taken seriously--for very different reasons--by generations of devoted believers and confirmed skeptics." Although his aim is not apologetics, by examining what the Book of Mormon "has meant, and might conceivably yet come to mean, to its various readerships," Givens maintains a climate in which belief may flourish. His work is a masterpiece.

I read By the Hand of Mormon as part of a book group formed by my good friend James Olsen. I recommend this book and James Olsen's book group without reservation. I'm thankful to the book group for renewing my belief that things are better understood when discussed with others. I'm thankful for Terryl Givens for strengthening my testimony of the truthfulness of the Book of Mormon through his careful, well-researched analysis.

This is an informative book. If your knowledge of the Book of Mormon is like mine--largely obtained by reading the Book itself and through a lifetime of Sunday school lessons, conference talks and discussion with members and non-members alike--then you will learn something by reading this book. Additionally, By the Hand of Mormon will increase your confidence that the Book is true. Given's careful examination of the facts reinforced my testimony and enhanced my ability to address my beliefs in academic terms.

Here is the description from the front flap: In By the Hand of Mormon "Givens examines the Book of Mormon's role as a divine testament of the Last Days and as a sacred sign of Joseph Smith's status as a modern-day prophet. He assesses its claim to be a history of the pre-Columbian peopling of the Western Hemisphere. . . . Givens explores how the Book of Mormon has been defined as a cultural product, the imaginative ravings of a rustic religion-maker more inspired by the winds of culture than the breath of God. He also investigates its status as a new American Bible . . . probes the Book's shifting relationship to Mormon doctrine and its changing reputation among theologians and scholars. Finally . . . Givens highlights the Book's role as the engine behind what may become the next world religion."

Here are a few nice excerpts on analyzing the Book of Mormon's theological merit: "Bruce R. McConkie gave canonical utterance to the logic of LDS testimony that continues to be a feature of member and missionary expression alike: "The Book of Mormon . . . stands as a witness to all the world that Joseph Smith was the Lord's anointed through whom the foundation was laid for the great latter-day work of restoration."

"As a result . . . the Book of Mormon was seldom presented --or received by the appreciative--in terms of its claims, arguments, or doctrine. Its a priori incarnation as sacred history inscribed in gold, together with the aura of supernatural origins always framed its mention, far overshadowed and even displaced whatever internal persuasiveness it might have had. And just as Joseph’s prophetic authority was guarantor of the text's sacred status, so the very presence of this voice speaking "out of the dust," predicted by scripture and verified by the voice of angels and human witnesses alike, was guarantor that Joseph was indeed a prophet of God."

Its status as authoritative text "polarizes the Book of Mormon's reception around the issue of authenticity rather than theological merit."

Givens borrows a framework for understanding this phenomenon from Russian critic Mikhail Bakhtin, who "argues that there are two modes of language by which we are influenced: authoritative discourse and internally persuasive discourse. The latter category is any language that makes its claim upon us on the basis of its logic, rhetorical appeal, compelling argument, or emotional sway. 'The authoritative word,' on the other hand, 'demands that we acknowledge it, that we make it our own; it binds us, quite independent of any power it might have to persuade us internally; we encounter it with its authority already fused to it.' Some language, in other words, is so wedded to an authoritative source that we find it difficult or impossible to assess the content as content. We cannot analyze, negotiate, critique, or selectively assimilate it."

March 22, 2007

Book Review: The Looming Tower:Al-Qaeda and the Road to 9/11 by Lawrence Wright

Grade: A

The New York Times named The Looming Tower one of the ten best books of 2006. I agree. This is a wonderful book that I wholeheartedly recommend to anyone wishing to understand the making of Al-Qaeda and the events leading to September 11, 2001. But don't expect this book to recount the tale told through the news. Instead, Wright explains the philosophical origins of Al-Qaeda, the history of Bin Laden's wealth and influence, including the construction empire built by his illiterate father, the relationship between the United States and Saudi Arabia, the formation of Al Qaeda, and the rise of the Taliban in Afghanistan. Wright ends the book in climactic fashion by telling the story of FBI agent John O'Neill, a brash, driven agent dedicated to ending Al Qaeda and capturing Bin Laden. Ultimately, O'Neill retires from the FBI in July 2001 due to inter-agency politics and problems resulting from his turbulent personal life. In the great irony of the book, O'Neill retires to become Chief of Security at the World Trade Center, where he dies on September 11, 2001, killed by the group he worked so hard to destroy. Its worth reading this book for O'Neill's story alone.


Rather than recount more details, I end with a humorous account about the Taliban's actions shortly after taking Kabul:

The fashion dictators demanded that a man's beard be longer than the grip of his hand. Violators went to jail until they were sufficiently bushy. A man with "Beatle-ly" hair would have his head shaved. Should a woman leave her home without her veil, "her home will be marked and her husband punished," the Taliban penal code decreed. The animals in the zoo--those that had not been stolen in previous administrations--were slain or left to starve. One zealous, perhaps mad, Taliban jumped into a bear's cage and cut off his nose, reputedly because the animal's "beard" was not long enough. Another fighter, intoxicated by events and his own power, leaped into the lion's den and cried out, "I am the lion now!" The lion killed him. Another Taliban soldier threw a grenade into the den, blinding the animal. These two, the noseless bear and the blind lion, together with two wolves, were the only animals that survived the Taliban rule.

"'Throw reason to the dogs,' read a sign posted on the wall of the office of the religious police, who were trained by the Saudis. 'It stinks of corruption.' And yet the Afghan people, so exhausted by war, initially embraced the imposition of this costly order.'"


February 25, 2007

Book Review: The Chosen by Chaim Potok

Grade: A-

I read The Chosen based on my wife Katie's recommendation. After reading the book in less than two days, I owe her a thank you and an apology. Katie, thank you for recommending a wonderful book. I apologize for calling it a 'kid's book,' and nearly refusing to read it. In lieu of a less-than-articulate description, I endorse the following statement from the Wall Street Journal: "Anyone who finds [The Chosen] is finding a jewel. Its themes are profound and universal. . . . It will stay on [my] bookshel[f] and be read again."--The Wall Street Journal.

In The Chosen, Potok tells the story of two Jewish boys in 1940's Brooklyn--Reuven and Daniel--who form an unlikely friendship after a baseball hit by Daniel, a Hassidic, strikes Reuven, a Modern Orthodox, in the eye. As their friendship develops, so does the social and political climate as the boys' fathers react differently to the potential for an Israeli state at the conclusion of World War II. Ultimately, the boys successfully maintain their friendship, while responsibly dealing with the conflicts between their fathers and their beliefs.

The novel's themes include the strength of friendship, the pursuit of truth, religion & the secular world, and father-son relationships; a father's advice on friendship; two views on how to raise a son; serious religious study; discussion of historic events in the context of the novel; and moral themes of family, friendship, religion, and life-long learning.


June 16, 2006

Book Review: The Brief History of the Dead by Kevin Brockmeier

Grade: B

In The Brief History of the Dead, Kevin Brockmeier explores death as a form of insomnia--that the will and memory of the living can perpetuate the lives of the dead, and vice-versa. Brockmeier's simple plot alternates between two realms--earth (home to the living) and "the City" (home to the dead). In the City, the dead continue living as long as someone on earth still remembers them. But the City's population is shrinking fast becasue a virus has killed all but one human on earth--antarctic researcher Laura Byrd. The remaining residents of the City are Byrd's acquaintances from earth. As she struggles to survive, the dead learn to live. Both rely on each other for survival. Byrd wills herself to live by remembering her family, friends, and acquaintances. City residents remain alive through her memory.

"That was what insomnia was, after all--an excess of consciousness, an excess of life. Ever since she could remember, she had treated her life as an act of will, the you-can-do-anything-you-set-your-mind-to philosophy, but she couldn't will herself to fall asleep. The only way to fall asleep was not to care whether you fell asleep or not: you had to relinquish your will. Most people seemed to think that you fell aslweep and then started dreaming, but as far as Minny could tell, the process was exactly the reverse--you started dreaming and that enabled you to fall asleep. She wasn't able to start dreaming, though, because she couldn't stop thinking about the fact that she wasn't already asleep."
While I recommend this book for its discussion of death and memory, I caution readers of its failings. Brockmeier succeeds by creating a powerful image of the link between the dead and the living--that the dead remain through the memory of the living. He fails because the characters and plot do not match his theme in power or depth. I felt little connection to any of the characters, alive or dead. I did, however, like the name of the central dead character--Luka--which is similar to my son's name--Lucas (even though Lucas was unborn at the time I read this book). Similarly, I found the plot predictable and lacking depth.


April 18, 2006

Bookseller: John Sandoe (Books) Ltd.

As I mentioned in an earlier post, I love listening to The Book Show on my iPod. Romana Koval is an excellent interviewer who gives each author time to tell his/her story. But what I like most is exposure to authors who have not published in the U.S. Ironically, this is also what I like least. These books are expensive and difficult to locate.

First I discovered Andrey Kurkov, author of Death and the Penguin, which has been published in the U.S. and is available at Amazon.com.

Death and the Penguin is a gripping novel about a man named Victor and his adopted pet penguin Misha. Aspiring author Victor is hired by a post-soviet, mob-owned newspaper to write obituaries for the undead. Eventually, as each obituary nears publication, the subject of each obituary dies. Kurkov takes us on a wild chase of reality amidst absurdity. . . Or is it absurdity amidst reality?. . . Or are they one and the same? As I see it, this is the point of the novel--that with time people will embrace absurdity as normality.

I finished Death and the Penguin in record time, only to learn that Kurkov wrote a sequel, Penguin Lost, and that it is only available in the UK. I searched and searched. Eventually I found a copy through Froogle, bought it, read it, and loved it.

That's when I decided to read all Kurkov's books. I found Case of the General's Thumb without too much trouble. A Matter of Death and Life, however, proved difficult. Several U.S. booksellers carried it, but most charged upwards of $25.

Which brings us to the point of this long-winded message: my wonderful mother and sister, and John Sandoe (Books) Ltd. Immediately upon learning that my mother and sister planned to visit London, England, I scoured the internet for a bookseller within walking distance of their hotel. I found John Sandoe (Books) Ltd. http://www.johnsandoe.com/.


I was after two books: Andrey Kurkov's Novella "A Matter of Death and Life," and Samuel Shimon's "An Iraqi in Paris: An Autobiographical Novel."
Neither is published in the United States. Thanks to my mother, sister, and John Sandoe (Books) Ltd. both now happily reside on my bookshelf.